WILMINGTON, VERMONT – November 13, 2026 -- A metal roof in Wilmington, Vermont, often costs two to three times as much as a comparable asphalt one, and a HelloNation article says it can last 40 to 70 years.
The piece, titled "Metal vs. Asphalt Roofing: Which Performs Better in Vermont?", draws on Ryan Adams, a Wilmington roofing expert. It compares how each material handles freeze-thaw cycles, heavy snow and ice dams.
Metal costs more up front but is said to last longer
The article puts the life of a properly installed metal roof in Wilmington at 40 to 70 years. It names steel and aluminum as the common residential metals and calls steel the usual recommendation for strength.
Asphalt architectural shingles come with warranties of 30 to 50 years under standard conditions. By our calculation, metal's stated lifespan runs 10 years longer at the low end and 20 years longer at the high end. That compares a lifespan with a warranty, because the article gives no asphalt lifespan.
The article says standing-seam metal sheds snow efficiently, which reduces structural load and limits ice dam formation. It also describes metal as highly resistant to moisture intrusion.
Asphalt shingles turn brittle in extreme cold
The article calls asphalt by far the most common material in the Wilmington area and says it suits most residential budgets. Its weak point is temperature extremes. Shingles can become brittle in very cold weather and crack under heavy snow or ice dam stress.
Poor ventilation makes this worse. Heat escaping from the living space warms the roof unevenly, which the article says promotes ice dams at the eaves. It says asphalt's longevity in cold climates depends on installation, especially ice and water shield along the eaves and in roof valleys.
Cedar, slate and synthetics each trade cost against upkeep
- Cedar shake: has natural insulating properties, but its oils deplete and it needs periodic treatment.
- Slate: can last more than a century, but cost, structural weight requirements and specialized labor limit its use.
- Synthetic slate and composite shingles: sit between natural stone and standard asphalt on cost, and some products are rated for cold climates and heavy snow loads.
The article gives no dollar prices for any of these options, so the actual cost gap between metal and asphalt is unknown.
Whatever the material, the article says installation quality is the variable that most directly determines how a roof performs in Wilmington. It names improper installation, poor ventilation and substandard underlayment as the factors that make even a well-chosen material underperform.